Exceptions to the Automatic Stay: Repeat Bankruptcy Filings

If you file a second bankruptcy within a year of a dismissal, the automatic stay ends after 30 days, and a third filing gets no stay unless the court orders one.

By , Attorney University of the Pacific McGeorge School of Law

The automatic stay is the court order that stops creditors from collecting from you the moment you file for bankruptcy. If you filed and had a case dismissed within the past year, the stay might be limited or unavailable, leaving you open to collection activity. Learn how the repeat-filing rules work, including how to ask the court to impose or extend the stay. You'll also learn what creditors can take when the stay isn’t in effect and which legal matters a bankruptcy filing never stops.

When Does the Automatic Stay Exception Apply to Repeat Filings?

The exception applies if you had one or more bankruptcy cases pending and dismissed within the year before you file again. How much protection you lose depends on how many cases you had.

Key Factor

One Dismissed Case in the Past Year

Two or More Dismissed Cases in the Past Year

Automatic Stay

The stay is put in place but lasts only 30 days.

The stay doesn't go into effect.

Court Relief

You can ask the court to extend the stay before the 30 days run out, but you'll need to show you filed in good faith.

You can file a motion to impose a stay within 30 days of filing, but you'll need to show you filed in good faith.

Your Burden

Overcome the presumption of bad faith with clear and convincing evidence.

Overcome the presumption of bad faith with clear and convincing evidence.

Here's how this works:

  • Two Bankruptcies Within One Year: Stay Limited to 30 Days. The court presumes you filed the second case in bad faith, and you can rebut that presumption. (11 U.S.C. § 362(c)(3).)
  • Three Bankruptcies Within One Year: No Automatic Stay. The court presumes bad faith, but you can ask the court to impose a stay. (11 U.S.C. § 362(c)(4).)
  • Joint Bankruptcy Filings: Your Spouse Might Get the Stay. If you file a joint bankruptcy with your spouse within a year of an individual case being dismissed, the restrictions apply to you. Your spouse might still be entitled to automatic stay protection, but courts disagree on whether the spouse keeps it. The stay won’t apply to your spouse if your spouse also filed multiple cases within the same year. A bankruptcy lawyer can tell you how courts in your area handle this.

Can I Ask the Bankruptcy Court to Impose or Extend the Automatic Stay?

Yes. You can file a motion asking the court to extend the automatic stay (second filing) or impose it (third filing). To prevail, you must present clear and convincing evidence that you filed in good faith. For a second filing, the hearing must be finished before the 30 days run out, so file the motion right away. (11 U.S.C. § 362(c).)

Suppose the bankruptcy court dismissed your previous bankruptcy because you didn’t file required bankruptcy documents on time. You show you didn’t intentionally fail to file the documents to force a dismissal. The court will probably extend the automatic stay if there’s no evidence of bad faith. You’ll also have a strong argument if you show the dismissal resulted from your attorney’s error, not your own.

Ultimately, the court doesn’t want to reward repeat filings that hold a particular creditor at bay. For instance, you won’t prevail if you repeatedly filed to stop a mortgage lender from foreclosing on your property. Special rules also apply when you dismiss a bankruptcy case after the court grants a mortgage lender’s motion to lift the automatic stay. (11 U.S.C. § 362(d)(4).)

When Can I Get a Discharge After a Previous Bankruptcy?

You can receive a discharge in a new case only if enough time has passed since you filed the earlier case. How long you must wait between filings depends on the chapters involved, and the clock runs from the date you filed the first case, not the date you received your discharge. The waiting period rules don't apply to cases dismissed without a discharge.

You aren't precluded from filing sooner, and sometimes it can be beneficial. In Chapter 7, the trustee would sell your nonexempt property, but you wouldn't receive a discharge. This is always the case for business entities other than sole proprietors who file for Chapter 7 because they aren't entitled to a discharge. It's helpful when you want to liquidate property transparently or don't want the responsibility of selling property and distributing assets to creditors.

Chapter 13 is often more beneficial because although you wouldn't receive a discharge, the automatic stay would prevent creditors from collecting while you pay off debts over three to five years. This works well when you need time to repay a debt (perhaps one you couldn't discharge in Chapter 7—such successive filings are sometimes referred to as "Chapter 20" bankruptcies) and want protection from wage garnishments, other collection actions, and lawsuits.

Earlier Case With a Discharge

New Case

Time Between Filing Dates

Chapter 7 or Chapter 11

Chapter 7

8 years

Chapter 7

Chapter 13

4 years

Chapter 13

Chapter 7

6 years (exceptions apply)

Chapter 13

Chapter 13

2 years

You don't need to wait six years to file for Chapter 7 after a Chapter 13 if you fully paid unsecured creditors, or paid at least 70%, and you proposed the plan in good faith. You can almost always immediately file back-to-back Chapter 13 cases and receive a discharge. The two-year rule rarely comes into play given that Chapter 13 cases last three to five years if the filer doesn't fully repay all debts. (11 U.S.C. § 727(a)(8), (a)(9); 11 U.S.C. § 1328(f).)

What Can Creditors Do If the Automatic Stay Isn’t in Effect?

Without the stay, creditors can resume collection activity, including calls, lawsuits, repossession, foreclosure, and wage garnishment. If the stay ends after 30 days in a second filing, most courts hold that it stays in place for property of the bankruptcy estate. Courts in other areas disagree. Even then, a creditor can’t simply take property in the bankruptcy estate, because the trustee controls it for the benefit of all creditors. (11 U.S.C. § 362(c)(3).)

So what’s in the bankruptcy estate? Everything you own when you file for bankruptcy.

Example. Suppose you own a 2006 Honda Civic protected by your state’s motor vehicle exemption when you file for bankruptcy. In most courts, your creditors still can’t take your car after a second-filing stay expires. It’s part of your bankruptcy estate and protected by the exemption.

What Isn’t in a Bankruptcy Estate?

In a Chapter 7 case, wages you earn after filing and property you buy with postfiling earnings aren’t part of the bankruptcy estate. If the stay isn’t in effect, your creditors can garnish your postfiling wages or take property you buy with postfiling income. In Chapter 13, postfiling earnings are part of the estate.

If you incur debt after filing, your new creditors aren’t subject to the automatic stay. They can call, bill, or sue you to attach property or garnish your wages.

Example. A creditor with a judgment against you can garnish wages you earn after your Chapter 7 filing if the automatic stay isn’t in effect. If the stay is in effect, the creditor must stop.

Why Won’t the Bankruptcy Court Order the Automatic Stay for Repeat Filings?

The rules prevent filers from repeatedly dismissing bankruptcy cases and exploiting the automatic stay’s ability to stop foreclosure, repossession, lawsuits, and other collection actions. Repeat filers often have no intention of using bankruptcy to fix financial problems, and many can’t qualify for Chapter 13. The bankruptcy court views bankruptcy manipulation as a bad-faith abuse of the bankruptcy process. The resulting delays unfairly harm creditors with valid payment and property claims.

Does Automatic Stay Abuse Occur More Frequently in Chapter 7 or 13 Cases?

Bad-faith filings occur much more often in Chapter 13 cases. Unlike Chapter 7 filers, Chapter 13 filers can generally dismiss a bankruptcy case without bankruptcy court approval. This allows debtors to file for bankruptcy to stop impending collection actions, such as foreclosures, then dismiss the case soon after and file again when the foreclosure sale is again set to occur. (11 U.S.C. § 1307(b).)

In Chapter 7, the bankruptcy court reviews a filer’s dismissal request and will deny it if it appears to be a bad-faith filing. The Chapter 7 filer’s case will move forward with the Chapter 7 trustee selling assets the filer can’t protect.

Chapter 13 trustees don’t sell property. Without guardrails and consequences for multiple filings after a dismissal, Chapter 13 filers would risk virtually nothing by filing in bad faith.

Other Exceptions to Bankruptcy’s Automatic Stay Protection

The automatic stay doesn’t stop several legal matters, no matter how many times you’ve filed. It applies to financial matters involved in your bankruptcy, not to many other legal issues you might face. (11 U.S.C. § 362(b).)

  • Criminal matters and administrative licensing cases. A bankruptcy filing won’t affect criminal cases or the collection of fines, restitution, and other debts ordered in criminal court. Government actions against a state-issued license will proceed—driver’s, professional, fishing, or another license type—and you’ll remain responsible for related fines.
  • Tax determinations. The IRS can proceed with tax audits and assessments during the bankruptcy case.
  • Family law matters. The automatic stay won’t stop scheduled court dates for divorce proceedings, custody determinations, and support awards.


How Do I Get the Relief the Automatic Stay Provides?

The automatic stay starts the moment you file, with no court order needed. Once it’s in place, creditors can’t contact you, bill you, sue you, or take other collection actions, like repossessing property or garnishing wages. If you file too often, you won’t receive that protection. Learn how the automatic stay can help you stop foreclosure and keep a house in bankruptcy. (11 U.S.C. § 362(a).)

Next Steps and More Bankruptcy Help

If you’ve filed before, talk to a bankruptcy lawyer before you file again. A lawyer can tell you whether the stay will apply and file a motion to extend or impose it on time. In the meantime, these articles might help:

If you need the official Chapter 7 and 13 bankruptcy forms, you’ll find them on the U.S. Courts Bankruptcy Forms webpage.

Get Professional Help
Find the right bankruptcy attorney for free.

What is your total debt?

Please select an answer
Continue

How It Works

  1. Briefly tell us about your case
  2. Provide your contact information
  3. Choose attorneys to contact you